Game 3 MTG Bulk Buylist

Sell your Magic: The Gathering bulk for cash, PayPal, or store credit.

Turn extra boxes of MTG cards into a fast, transparent payout. Submit your estimated counts, drop off in Oakville or ship them to us, and we’ll confirm the final total after inspection.

Start Your Submission View Current Rates
$

Know your estimate before submitting

The calculator below shows your estimated payout based on your card counts and our current MTG bulk rates.

✓

Simple drop-off or mail-in process

Bring the cards to our Oakville store or ship them to us. Either way, include your submission name.

↗

We buy more than just bulk

Have singles or a full collection too? Use our general buylist

Current MTG Bulk Rates

These are estimated payout rates before inspection. Final payout may change based on condition, rarity, sorting, and contents.

Commons & Uncommons$5 / 1,000$0.005 per card
Rares$50 / 1,000$0.05 per card
Mythics$100 / 1,000$0.10 per card
Basic Lands$3 / 1,000$0.003 per card

How selling your MTG bulk works

A clean, simple process from estimate to final payout.

Count your cards

Separate by rarity when possible: C/U, rares, mythics, and basic lands.

Submit the form

Enter your estimated counts and contact information using the submission form below.

Drop off or ship

Bring the cards to our Oakville store or mail them in at your shipping expense.

Get your final total

We inspect the cards, confirm the final payout, then pay by cash, PayPal, or store credit.

What we accept

  • Magic: The Gathering commons and uncommons
  • MTG rares, mythics, foils, and mixed bulk
  • Basic lands, including large quantities
  • Older sets, newer sets, commander cards, and mixed collections
  • Sorted or unsorted submissions, with rates adjusted accordingly

What may affect payout

  • Damaged, heavily played, marked, or unsellable cards
  • Incorrect rarity counts or large count differences
  • Non-MTG cards mixed into the submission
  • Basic lands included in other categories
  • Shipping damage from poorly packed boxes

Local drop-off available in Oakville

Dropping off in-store is the easiest option. Pack your cards securely, mention the name used on your submission, and our team will review the cards as quickly as possible.

Game 3 1011 Upper Middle Road, Unit C15
Oakville, ON L6H 4L3

Mention your submission name when dropping off.

Submit your MTG bulk estimate

Enter your estimated totals below. The form will calculate an estimated payout before you submit.

Submit Your MTG Bulk

Enter your estimated card counts below and we’ll follow up with a confirmed total and next steps.

If shipping, you are responsible for all shipping costs.
MTG bulk breakdown (total cards)
$5.00 per 1,000 • $0.005/ea
Estimated value: $0.000
$50.00 per 1,000 • $0.05/ea
Estimated value: $0.000
$3.00 per 1,000 • $0.003/ea
Estimated value: $0.000
$100.00 per 1,000 • $0.10/ea
Estimated value: $0.000
Estimated cash total (before inspection): $0.00
This is an estimated payout based on your counts and our current bulk rates. Final payout may change after condition and rarity checks.
Important: this form gives an estimated payout only. Final payout is confirmed after we inspect condition, sorting, rarity, and the actual card counts. If shipping, you are responsible for all shipping costs.
✓

✅ Thanks! Your MTG bulk submission has been sent. We’ll reply by email soon.

MTG Bulk Buylist FAQ

A few quick answers to common questions about selling your Magic: The Gathering bulk to us.

1. Do the cards need to be sorted? ▶

Sorting by rarity (C/U, R/M, Basic Lands) is required if your submission is per-rarity. If your submission is not sorted, it will be taken at the non-sorted rate & any basic lands will be at their own rate of $3/1000.

Unsorted cards are still accepted at the Non-Sorted MTG Lot rate.

2. What condition do the cards need to be in? ▶

Listed prices are based on Near Mint bulk. Any LP cards will be accepted at a slightly reduced rate.

Any cards MP or lower will be sent back (at your own expense, via invoice from us).

3. How do I drop off bulk in-store? ▶

You can bring your bulk to our retail store:
1011 Upper Middle Road, Unit C15, Oakville ON, L6H 4L3.

(Mention your submission name when dropping off.)

We'll inspect your cards the same day or next business day.

4. Can I ship bulk to you instead? ▶

Yes! You may ship your bulk to us — but shipping costs are your responsibility.

We recommend:

  • Double-boxing for safety
  • Taping each row closed
  • Including your submission name on the outside of the box as well as on the inside
5. How long does it take to get paid? ▶

Most bulk payments are completed within:

  • Same day (or next) for in-store drop-offs (depending on the day and time)
  • 24–48 hours after receiving your shipment for mail-ins

We pay via cash, PayPal & store credit.

6. Do you accept all sets and eras? ▶

Yes – we accept all MTG sets. Older sets, newer sets, mixed collections – everything is fine.

7. What if my counts are slightly off? ▶

Minor differences happen and are totally okay.

We will:

  • Recount
  • Adjust the total
  • Email you your final payout breakdown
8. Do you buy more than just bulk? ▶

Yes. We also buy all singles & full collections (no sealed product).

You can find our general buylist at https://buylist.game3.ca/retailer/buylist .

If you're selling a full collection, please use our buylist feature for a quote. If you are unsure of the contents, please email or call us for assistance.

9. Do lands count as basics or bulk? ▶

Basic lands are bought at their own rate. Full-art basics or special promos may be valued separately (often higher).

10. What forms of payment do you offer? ▶

We offer:

  • Cash
  • PayPal
  • Store credit